丹麦宫颈癌筛查中 HPV 检测与细胞学检测的比较分析:来自大规模实施研究的见解。
Comparative analysis of HPV testing versus cytology in Danish cervical cancer screening: Insights from a large-scale implementation study.
发表日期:2024 Sep 27
作者:
Sofie Lindquist, Susanne K Kjær, Kirsten Frederiksen, Dorthe Ørnskov, Christian Munk, Marianne Waldstrøm
来源:
GYNECOLOGIC ONCOLOGY
摘要:
人乳头瘤病毒 (HPV) 检测是推荐的宫颈癌主要筛查方法。丹麦于 2021 年开始实施 HPV 检测作为主要筛查方法,但尚未提供全国数据。我们报告了丹麦大型试点实施研究中第一轮和第二轮筛选的结果。目的是比较阴道镜转诊,识别高级别宫颈上皮内瘤变 (CIN) 和癌症,以及基于 HPV 和基于细胞学的筛查之间的阳性预测值 (PPV)。 在 HPV SCREEN DENMARK 队列(2017 年 5 月至 12 月建立)中2019 年),参与者根据居住城市被分配到基于 HPV 的筛查(n = 28,677)或基于细胞学的筛查(n = 43,622)。第一轮筛查显示 HPV 组的阴道镜检查转诊率更高(6.4%)。细胞学检查 (2.3 %),HPV 筛查检测到的 CIN3 (n = 306/28,677 (1.1 %)) 多于细胞学检查 (n = 241/43,622 (0.6 %)) (RR = 1.9 (95 % CI 1.6-2.3))。从绝对数量来看,每 1000 名接受筛查的女性中,另外 41 次阴道镜检查转诊导致额外检测出 10 例 CIN2 病例和 5 例额外 CIN3 病例。HPV 组中通过常规筛查启动的阴道镜检查中 CIN3 的 PPV 相似 (24.1%),而细胞学组(25.7%)在筛查的最初几年内,与细胞学组相比,HPV 组的 CIN3 和宫颈癌的累积发病率增加得更快。基于 HPV 的宫颈筛查检测到的 CIN3 病例几乎是细胞学组的两倍,但其代价是阴道镜检查转诊次数增加了两倍多。此外,我们发现基于 HPV 的筛查比基于细胞学的筛查更早发现宫颈癌。版权所有 © 2024。由 Elsevier Inc. 出版。
Human papillomavirus (HPV) testing is the recommended primary screening method against cervical cancer. Denmark started implementing HPV testing as a primary screening method in 2021, but no national data are yet available. We report the results of the first and second screening rounds in a large Danish pilot implementation study. The objective was to compare colposcopy referrals, identify high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and cancer, and positive predictive value (PPV) between HPV-based and cytology-based screening.In the HPV SCREEN DENMARK cohort (established May 2017-December 2019), participants were assigned to HPV-based (n = 28,677) or cytology-based screening (n = 43,622) based on the municipality of residence.The first round of screening showed higher colposcopy referrals in the HPV group (6.4 %) compared to cytology (2.3 %), with HPV screening detecting more CIN3+ (n = 306/28,677 (1.1 %)) than cytology (n = 241/43,622 (0.6 %)) (RR = 1.9 (95 %CI 1.6-2.3). In absolute terms, 41 additional colposcopy referrals resulted in the detection of 10 more cases of CIN2+ and five extra CIN3+ cases per 1000 women screened. The PPV for CIN3+ of a colposcopy initiated by routine screening was similar in the HPV group (24.1 %) and cytology group (25.7 %). Within the initial years of screening, the cumulative incidence of CIN3+ and cervical cancer showed a more rapid increase in the HPV group compared to the cytology group.HPV-based cervical screening detects almost twice as many CIN3+ cases but at the expense of a more than two-fold increase in colposcopy referrals. Furthermore, we found that HPV-based screening detects cervical cancer earlier than cytology-based screening.Copyright © 2024. Published by Elsevier Inc.